Unaccustomed as I am…

I have never written to my MP before, any MP actually…but I decided to give it a go to see if it would stop me ranting on Facebook!

Dear Mr Moon

I hope that you are well.

I felt compelled to write after the recent press coverage about ‘donations’ and gifts that seem to be considered as being an acceptable perk for MP’s and ministers.  I’m not sure whether you will read this directly, or respond to me, but wanted to express my thoughts about the apparent hypocrisy that is frustratingly on show within the new Labour government.

First of all, I want to stress that my views are not party political.  I’m not affiliated to any party and feel that, whilst we may not agree with their politics, most MP’s have the best interests of their constituents at heart – to begin with at least.  However, it is very easy to become disillusioned with our leaders when listening to their justification for accepting gifts from rich benefactors, businessmen and organisations.

After so many years of listening to arguments and accusations from opposition benches about Tory sleaze, and how the Conservative Party were out of touch with the British public, it baffles me how the Labour leadership have put themselves into this position so soon after the election victory.  The Labour Party were meant to be the party of the people, an antidote for the Conservatives who were making people poorer, the only growth being poverty and the ever-important food bank industry.  I would watch PMQ’s, and it was often too easy for opposition MPs to hurl abuse at the PM or cabinet ministers, accusing them of hurting the poorest in society or not understanding the plight of the common man, the struggle of living from one payday to the next, or choosing between ‘heating and eating’.

I’m not that naïve to understand how the real world works though.

The Labour Party leadership have come under scrutiny, and for good reason.  If you are going to criticise others for their alleged impropriety or underhandedness, then you should at least ensure that there are no skeletons in your own closets or ways in which opponents could turn the tables on you.  And again, I am baffled that seemingly intelligent people cannot understand why the voting public would be feeling a certain amount of outrage when listening to stories of gifts being given to their representatives whilst carrying out their duties as public servants.

Our MPs receive our votes to speak on our behalf as constituents, to look after our interests and work to improve our standard of living.  Why does it feel as though some of our representatives are using their position to improve their own situation first and foremost?  The argument from the likes of Angela Rayner, Kier Starmer, and other ministers, is that this is the system and as long as they declare what they receive then they are being transparent and sticking to the rules.  The claim that they are Party donations is also embarrassing, and the terminology should immediately be changed.

Donations to political parties should be allowed, but there should be strict rules, much more strict that they are at present anyway.  If a cash donation, or a physical item, that is used to help fund a political party or help with a campaign is received, it should be allowed if received by the party itself and distributed accordingly.  This will ensure that everything is accounted for, and no individual will be responsible for it.  There should be no suggestion that a party donation can illicit favours or preferential treatment in any way.

A gift of designer clothing, designer spectacles, Taylor Swift tickets, festival tickets, holiday apartments, holidays, an apartment to complete GCSE studies…these are not donations.  These are gifts provided as a direct benefit of their position as an MP, cabinet minister, or Prime Minister.  Surely that is wrong on many levels.  None more so that the possible accusation of the potential for bribery and corruption, preferential treatment or favours.  Shall we mention Lord Alli’s Downing Street pass?

These stories have come to light at a time when the Labour Party are talking about the difficult decisions that they need to make, the hardships that some will have to face to get the economy back on track after 14 years of a Tory government.  These stories of the PM taking gifts totalling more than £100k, other MP’s accepting gifts totalling thousands of pounds for clothing and concert tickets, football matches and holidays.  I keep on mentioning it as I am becoming increasingly furious about it.

These stories have come at time when the first difficult decision for the chancellor to make, the chancellor herself who has benefitted from gifts totalling thousands from donors, is taking the Winter Fuel Payment away from most pensioners this year.  Those pensioners who are lucky enough to claim pension credits will still receive it, of course, but when you need to be ‘earning’ in the region of £12,000 to be eligible for pension credits, you’re not exactly going to be swinging from your chandeliers with joy and immediately getting the decorators in to spruce up the west wing of your council bungalow, are you!  And I’m sure that our PM and his cabinet ministers know what a pittance £12k is these days.  It will barely buy you a pair of designer glasses or a smart suit to wear at the next Taylor Swift after party!

Whilst our Prime Minister and his MPs are accepting these gifts, without embarrassment, they are defending themselves with no irony whatsoever.  When talking about them they claim to be following the rules, but ethically it stinks.  Joe Public would love to be able to slip on some designer threads, or get into next years Oasis or Coldplay shows.  They’d love to be able to experience hospitality at Old Trafford, Man City or Spurs.  Heck, some people would just love to be able to have three square meals and eat them with the heating on – if only for a half an hour to take the chill off.

To put the cherry on top, Kier Starmer justified taking a donation to provide an apartment for his son to study away from the glare of the media as something any parent would want to do to protect their family.  All parents want the best for the families, I agree.  However, not everyone can rely on a gift from a wealthy donor who, may or may not, expect the favour to be reciprocated at a later date.

If we can put this whole situation in context.  An MP, as I understand, earns a basic pay of £91,346 per year.  On top of that they can claim expenses for staff, constituency offices, a second home near parliament, travel and other living allowances (including utility bills – although I’m happy to be corrected).  So, as they take away the winter fuel allowance for pensioners, they are earning, very possibly, ten times more than those old folk who have worked most of their lives to pay into a system that no longer seems to care.

Kier Starmer, and some of the other MP’s and (shadow) ministers, were happy to berate Rishi Sunak for being out of touch with the British people – how can somebody with such wealth understand how it feels to be on the breadline, unable to turn the heating on or eat a decent meal?  They would often talk about their working class credentials, all the while taking freebies and gifts as a direct benefit of their jobs and position.  No other industry would allow this!

And, whilst Sir Kier Starmer is taking the gifts and freebies, watching football in the posh seats, wearing his designer glasses and wearing his expensive suits, all paid for by his friends and benefactors, he himself has a net worth of several millions of pounds.  The hypocrisy astounds me!  Although it shouldn’t be a surprise.  The PM, his deputy leader (who I had always thought was against this sort of cronyism and nest-feathering) and all of the other ministers and MP’s who take advantage in this way should take this opportunity to evaluate what is important as their role as a public servant.  You as MP’s, from all parties, are rewarded extremely well, you play an important role.  However, please do not talk about difficult decisions, or how Joe Public will need to take some pain to get us out of this financial mess when, as it is being described, MP’s and ministers are all ‘eating out of the same trough’.

Political decisions are made by governments every day and can affect different people in society in many different ways.  Political parties will have an ideology and if we do not agree with it, we simply have to live with it until the next election.  We can moan and groan all we like, but that is how a democracy works and the governing party will do as they see fit.  This is a situation that transcends politics, though.  When train drivers get a pay rise when they already earn £60,000, at a time when pensioners are having much needed funds taken away from them, I don’t agree with that at all.  But that is a political decision, and very much to do with keeping the Unions happy, I suspect.  Accepting thousands of pounds worth of free gifts, over and above legitimate party donations, that is most certainly not about politics.

I am sure that you must be inundated with correspondence about this matter, but appreciate your time in reading this.

Over the last few years, starting in 2021 when I was diagnosed with cancer for the second time, we started raising money to donate into various organisations at Christmastime.  This year we are doing the same and donating into RCHT-Treliske paediatric ward, St Petrocs, Children’s Hospice South West, the Armed Forces and Veterans Breakfast Club and Hayle Food Bank.  We’ve seen that our donations, even in a small way, can help raise a smile when times are tough, and I think that is why these stories about donations to ministers and MP’s is so difficult to hear.  There are people desperate for support, positivity and optimism and to see wealthy people in power talk about making difficult decisions, when they are feathering their own nests, it is incredibly frustrating.

Kind regards

David

Leave a Reply